Introduction
Owning a rental property can provide steady income, but it also comes with risks that ordinary homeowners insurance may not be designed to handle. A tenant could damage the property, a visitor could be injured, or a covered loss could make the home temporarily unlivable and interrupt your rental income.
That is why choosing the best landlord insurance matters.
The right policy should do more than protect the building. It should also help address liability risks, landlord-owned property, lost rental income, and other exposures associated with renting a property.
There is no single insurer that is best for every landlord. The right choice depends on your property type, location, rental arrangement, coverage needs, deductible, claims history, and budget.
This guide compares six landlord insurance options and explains what each may be best suited for. It also shows what landlord insurance covers, how much it can cost, what to compare, and the mistakes property owners should avoid.
Quick Answer: What Is the Best Landlord Insurance?
The best landlord insurance is not necessarily the policy with the lowest premium. It is the policy that provides appropriate protection for your rental property at a price you can afford.
Six providers worth comparing in 2026 include:
| Provider | Best For | Main Reason to Consider |
| American Family | Traditional rental properties | Broad landlord-focused protection |
| Steadily | Rental-property investors | Specialized landlord insurance approach |
| Travelers | 1–4 unit properties | Established rental-property coverage |
| biBerk | Business-minded landlords | Business insurance focus |
| Proper | Short-term rentals | Specialized vacation-rental approach |
| State Farm | Local-agent support | Personalized insurance guidance |
Availability, eligibility, coverage limits, exclusions, deductibles, and pricing vary by state and property.
So, use this list as a starting point for comparison, not as a guarantee that one company will be cheapest or best for your specific property.
Key Facts About Landlord Insurance
| Key Fact | What It Means |
| Designed for rental properties | Coverage is built around risks associated with renting property to tenants. |
| Protects the structure | Covered damage to the rental dwelling may be insured up to the policy limit. |
| Liability protection may be included | Helps address certain third-party injury or property-damage claims. |
| Lost rent may be covered | Some policies can replace rental income after a qualifying covered loss. |
| Tenant belongings are different | A landlord policy generally does not insure a tenant’s personal possessions. |
| Coverage differs by insurer | Limits, exclusions, deductibles, and endorsements can vary substantially. |
| Short-term rentals need special attention | Airbnb and similar activity may require specialized coverage. |
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners explains that landlord policies can provide protection for the rental property, liability, lost rental income, and certain owner-owned contents, depending on the policy. NAIC consumer insurance information
6 Best Landlord Insurance Options for 2026
Instead of declaring one company universally “best,” the following six options are organized around different landlord needs.
That approach is more useful because a landlord with one long-term rental has very different insurance requirements from someone operating several vacation rentals.
1. American Family — Best for Traditional Landlords
American Family is worth considering for landlords who own conventional rental properties and want access to a traditional insurance provider.
Its landlord insurance information describes coverage for the rental dwelling and liability, with potential protection for lost rental income under qualifying circumstances.
Why consider American Family:
- Landlord-focused coverage
- Building protection
- Liability protection
- Potential rental-income protection
- Online quote options
- Agent support
Potential limitation: Availability and exact policy features vary by state and property.
Best fit: Owners of traditional long-term rental homes who want a mainstream insurer with agent support.
2. Steadily — Best for Rental-Property Investors
Steadily takes a specialized approach to landlord insurance rather than treating rental property as an ordinary homeowners risk.
Its platform focuses specifically on rental-property owners and provides options for several types of rental properties.
This specialized approach can be useful for investors who own different types of properties or want an insurance provider familiar with landlord-specific risks.
Why consider Steadily:
- Focus on rental properties
- Digital-first experience
- Landlord-specific insurance approach
- Options for different rental-property types
- Designed with real estate investors in mind
Potential limitation: Eligibility and available coverage depend on the property and location.
Best fit: Investors who want a provider focused specifically on rental-property insurance.
3. Travelers — Best for 1–4 Unit Rental Properties
Travelers is another strong option to investigate, particularly for qualifying residential rental properties.
Its landlord insurance information describes coverage for properties with one to four units, including certain single-family homes, multifamily homes, apartments, and condominiums.
Potential coverage can include:
- Property protection
- Premises liability
- Medical payments
- Other available policy options
Why consider Travelers:
- Established insurance provider
- Designed for qualifying rental properties
- Liability coverage
- Property protection
- Agent support
Potential limitation: Policy availability and terms differ by state.
Best fit: Landlords with qualifying one- to four-unit rental properties.
4. biBerk — Best for Business-Minded Landlords
biBerk may be worth considering when rental-property ownership is part of a broader business operation.
This can be particularly relevant for landlords who operate through a business entity or have additional commercial insurance needs.
Why consider biBerk:
- Business-oriented insurance approach
- Online-focused experience
- Broader commercial insurance ecosystem
- Potential fit for business owners
Potential limitation: A business-focused insurance solution is not automatically the best fit for a simple residential rental.
Your ownership structure and property use should be discussed with the insurer.
Best fit: Landlords who treat rental property as part of a broader business operation.
5. Proper — Best for Short-Term Rentals
A short-term rental is not the same risk as a traditional year-long lease.
A vacation rental may have frequent guest turnover, different occupancy patterns, and more frequent use by people who are unfamiliar with the property.
That makes specialized short-term-rental insurance worth investigating.
Why consider specialized coverage:
- Designed around short-term rental risks
- Better suited to frequent guest turnover
- May address vacation-rental activity more directly
- Useful for Airbnb and similar rental arrangements
Potential limitation: Short-term rental coverage can have specific eligibility rules and exclusions.
Best fit: Owners who regularly rent properties to short-term guests.
The NAIC recommends that homeowners discuss home-sharing activity with their insurer because standard homeowners coverage may not provide the protection owners expect when they rent their homes to paying guests. NAIC home-sharing insurance guidance
6. State Farm — Best for Local-Agent Support
Some landlords prefer speaking directly with an insurance professional rather than managing everything through an online platform.
State Farm can be worth comparing for those property owners because its agent-based model provides an opportunity to discuss the property’s specific risks and insurance needs.
Why consider State Farm:
- Local-agent model
- Personalized assistance
- Broad insurance product ecosystem
- Potential bundling opportunities
- Useful for landlords who prefer human guidance
Potential limitation: The final price and available coverage depend on the property, location, and underwriting.
Best fit: Landlords who value working with a local insurance professional.
How to Compare the Best Landlord Insurance Companies
Comparing insurers only by their advertised premiums can lead to the wrong decision.
Instead, compare the policies using the same coverage limits and deductibles.
| What to Compare | Why It Matters |
| Dwelling limit | Determines how much building protection you have. |
| Liability limit | Helps determine your protection against qualifying liability claims. |
| Loss of rent | Can help replace rental income after a covered loss. |
| Deductible | Determines how much you pay before insurance responds. |
| Covered perils | Shows which causes of loss are covered. |
| Exclusions | Identifies risks the policy does not cover. |
| Other structures | Important for detached garages, sheds, and similar structures. |
| Landlord contents | May protect appliances or furnishings you provide. |
| Vacancy rules | Important if the property becomes unoccupied. |
| Short-term rental rules | Critical for Airbnb and vacation rentals. |
Why the Cheapest Quote May Not Be the Best
Imagine two policies:
Policy A: $850 per year with lower liability limits and fewer optional protections.
Policy B: $980 per year with higher liability protection and better coverage for the landlord’s specific rental situation.
The second policy costs more, but it could provide significantly better protection.
The correct question is not:
“Which policy costs less?”
It is:
“Which policy gives me the protection I actually need for the money I am paying?”
What Does Landlord Insurance Cover?
Landlord insurance is generally designed around the risks associated with owning and renting property.
The exact protection depends on the policy.
Dwelling Coverage
Dwelling coverage protects the physical rental structure against covered losses.
Depending on the policy, this can include components such as:
- Walls
- Roof
- Floors
- Built-in systems
- Permanently attached fixtures
The coverage limit should be based on an appropriate estimate of rebuilding costs rather than simply the property’s selling price.
Other Structures
Some policies provide protection for detached structures.
Examples may include:
- Detached garages
- Sheds
- Fences
- Certain other structures
Always check the policy limits.
Landlord-Owned Contents
If you provide appliances, furniture, or other items for tenant use, certain landlord policies may cover those items against qualifying losses.
Examples can include:
- Refrigerator
- Stove
- Washer
- Dryer
- Furnishings
The tenant’s personal belongings are a separate matter.
Liability Coverage
Liability coverage can help protect the landlord against certain claims involving bodily injury or property damage.
For example, suppose a visitor falls on a dangerous condition at your rental property and claims that you were responsible.
A landlord liability policy may help with qualifying claims, subject to the policy’s limits and exclusions.
Loss of Rental Income
Some landlord policies provide coverage for lost rental income after a covered event makes the property temporarily uninhabitable.
This can be especially important if your rent is used to pay:
- Mortgage payments
- Property taxes
- Maintenance
- Utilities
- Property-management expenses
The policy determines when the coverage applies and how much can be paid.
What Does Landlord Insurance Not Cover?
Landlord insurance does not mean every problem with your rental property is automatically covered.
Common exclusions or limitations can include:
- Normal wear and tear
- Poor maintenance
- Certain floods
- Earthquake damage
- Intentional damage
- Certain pest problems
- Tenant belongings
- Certain vacancy situations
- Unauthorized rental activity
These are general examples rather than a universal list.
Always read the policy’s exclusions because coverage varies by insurer.
Landlord Insurance vs. Homeowners Insurance
This is one of the most important distinctions for property owners.
| Feature | Homeowners Insurance | Landlord Insurance |
| Owner lives in property | Usually | Usually not |
| Rental-property focus | Limited | Yes |
| Building protection | Yes | Yes |
| Tenant-related risks | Limited | Specifically considered |
| Landlord liability | Not primary purpose | Important component |
| Lost rental income | Generally not the main purpose | May be included |
| Tenant belongings | No | No |
| Short-term rental | May be restricted | May require specialized coverage |
A standard homeowners policy should not simply be assumed to cover a home once you start renting it.
Progressive explains that landlord or dwelling-fire insurance can be used for certain rental properties and may provide protection for the structure, liability, landlord-owned property, and lost rental income depending on the policy. Progressive landlord insurance guidance
Important: Tell your insurer how the property is actually being used.
How Much Does Landlord Insurance Cost?
There is no universal landlord insurance price.
Your premium can depend on many factors, including:
- Property location
- Rebuilding cost
- Property age
- Roof condition
- Construction type
- Number of units
- Rental type
- Claims history
- Liability limits
- Deductible
- Security features
- Vacancy
- Local weather risks
The NAIC explains that landlord insurance can cost more than standard homeowners insurance because of the additional risks associated with renting a property. NAIC consumer guidance
Why There Is No Single “Average” Price
Two landlords can own properties that appear nearly identical but receive completely different quotes.
For example:
Landlord A
- Newer roof
- No recent claims
- Long-term tenant
- Low-risk location
Landlord B
- Older roof
- Previous claims
- Short-term guests
- Higher-risk location
The insurer may consider Landlord B a higher risk even if both homes have similar market values.
That is why personalized quotes are more useful than relying on one generic price.
What Factors Can Increase Landlord Insurance Costs?
Property Location
Areas with higher exposure to hurricanes, severe storms, wildfires, flooding, or other hazards can affect insurance costs and coverage availability.
Older Property
Older roofs, electrical systems, plumbing, and heating systems can increase underwriting concerns.
Short-Term Rental Activity
Frequent guest turnover can create different risks than a traditional long-term tenant.
Claims History
Previous insurance claims can affect how an insurer evaluates your risk.
Higher Coverage Limits
Higher limits generally mean more protection, but they can also increase the premium.
How to Get Affordable Landlord Insurance
You do not have to sacrifice useful protection just to find a lower premium.
Use these steps.
1. Compare Multiple Quotes
Get quotes from several insurers using comparable coverage.
Otherwise, you may end up comparing completely different policies.
2. Keep Your Property Well Maintained
Regular maintenance can reduce preventable risks.
Pay particular attention to:
- Roof condition
- Plumbing
- Electrical systems
- Smoke alarms
- Locks
- Security systems
- Heating and cooling systems
3. Choose a Sensible Deductible
A higher deductible can sometimes reduce the premium.
But do not select a deductible that would create financial trouble after a claim.
4. Ask About Discounts
Depending on the insurer, discounts may be available for things such as:
- Multiple policies
- Security systems
- Updated roofs
- Protective devices
- Claims-free history
- Multiple properties
5. Review Your Coverage Every Year
Your insurance needs can change.
You may:
- Renovate the property
- Buy another rental
- Change tenants
- Convert to short-term rentals
- Add an LLC
- Add expensive appliances
- Increase the property’s value
Your insurance should change when the risk changes.
Landlord Insurance for Different Property Types
Single-Family Rental
A typical single-family rental may need dwelling protection, liability coverage, and loss-of-rent protection.
Duplex or Multi-Unit Property
Multi-unit properties may require different underwriting and coverage limits.
Make sure the insurer knows exactly how many units are on the property.
Condo Rental
Condo owners should understand where the association’s master policy ends and the individual owner’s insurance begins.
Short-Term Vacation Rental
Do not assume a normal landlord policy automatically covers Airbnb or similar activity.
Ask specifically about short-term guests.
Vacant Rental
If the property becomes vacant for an extended period, notify your insurer.
Vacancy can change the property’s risk profile and may trigger special policy conditions.
Rental Owned by an LLC
If an LLC owns the property, make sure the policy correctly reflects the ownership arrangement and named insured.
Common Landlord Insurance Mistakes
Mistake 1: Buying Only on Price
The cheapest quote is not necessarily the best value.
Mistake 2: Keeping Homeowners Insurance After Renting the Property
Changing occupancy without informing your insurer can create potential coverage problems.
Mistake 3: Underestimating Rebuilding Costs
Market value and reconstruction cost are not the same thing.
Mistake 4: Choosing Too Little Liability Coverage
Landlords can face claims involving tenants, visitors, contractors, and other third parties.
Mistake 5: Assuming Tenant Belongings Are Covered
Your landlord policy generally protects your property—not the tenant’s furniture, electronics, clothing, or other personal possessions.
The NAIC explains that renters need their own insurance to protect their belongings. NAIC renters insurance guidance
Mistake 6: Forgetting Flood Risk
Flood damage may not be covered by a standard property policy.
Depending on the location, separate flood insurance may need to be considered.
Mistake 7: Not Updating the Insurer
Major renovations, new structures, vacancies, or changes in rental use should be reported.
Expert Tips for Choosing the Right Policy
Use this checklist before purchasing:
- Calculate an appropriate dwelling limit.
- Compare liability limits across insurers.
- Ask whether lost rental income is covered.
- Check the deductible carefully.
- Read major exclusions.
- Confirm your exact rental arrangement is eligible.
- Ask about vacant-property rules.
- Ask about short-term rental restrictions.
- Check whether landlord-owned appliances are covered.
- Review your policy after renovations or major changes.
The goal is not to buy every possible coverage.
The goal is to identify the risks that could seriously affect your property or finances and make sure the policy addresses them appropriately.
A Real-World Example of Comparing Two Policies
Imagine you own a rental home worth $300,000.
You receive two quotes.
| Feature | Quote A | Quote B |
| Annual premium | $900 | $1,050 |
| Dwelling limit | $300,000 | $350,000 |
| Liability limit | $100,000 | $300,000 |
| Deductible | $2,500 | $1,500 |
| Lost-rent coverage | Limited | Included under qualifying conditions |
Quote A looks cheaper.
But Quote B may provide better protection for your specific situation.
That does not automatically make Quote B the correct choice. The point is that the premium should be considered alongside coverage, limits, exclusions, and your financial ability to handle a claim.
Pros and Cons of Landlord Insurance
| Pros | Cons |
| Protects the rental building | Adds an insurance expense |
| Can provide liability protection | Deductibles still apply |
| May protect lost rental income | Coverage differs between insurers |
| Can cover landlord-owned property | Some risks need separate insurance |
| Designed for rental-property risks | Short-term rentals may need specialized coverage |
| Can help protect investment income | Higher limits can increase premiums |
What Should You Ask Before Buying Landlord Insurance?
Before accepting a quote, ask:
- Is this policy specifically designed for rental use?
- What exactly is covered?
- What are the major exclusions?
- How much liability coverage is included?
- Is lost rental income covered?
- What deductible applies?
- Are detached structures covered?
- Are appliances covered?
- What happens if the property becomes vacant?
- Is Airbnb or short-term rental activity covered?
- Does the policy recognize my LLC?
- Is flood damage excluded?
- Are there any special endorsements I need?
- How are claims handled?
Getting clear answers before buying is much easier than discovering a coverage gap after a loss.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Landlord Insurance
What is landlord insurance?
Landlord insurance is coverage designed for property owners who rent their residential property to tenants. Depending on the policy, it can protect the building, landlord-owned property, liability exposure, and lost rental income after qualifying covered losses.
Do I legally need landlord insurance?
There is not one nationwide rule requiring every landlord to purchase the same landlord policy. However, mortgage lenders may require insurance, and state or local rules can create additional requirements.
Always check your lender and applicable local requirements.
Is landlord insurance more expensive than homeowners insurance?
It can be. Rental properties create additional risks, including tenant-related liability and potential rental-income losses. Pricing depends heavily on the property and coverage.
Does landlord insurance cover tenant belongings?
Generally, no.
The landlord’s policy is intended to protect the landlord’s property and financial interests. Tenants normally need renters insurance to protect their own belongings.
Does landlord insurance cover lost rent?
Some policies provide loss-of-rental-income coverage after a qualifying covered event makes the property uninhabitable.
The amount and duration depend on the policy.
Does landlord insurance cover Airbnb?
Not automatically.
Short-term rentals can require specialized coverage. Always tell the insurer how frequently and through which platform the property is rented.
Can I use homeowners insurance for a rental property?
You should not assume that you can.
Tell your insurer that the property is being rented. The insurer can determine what type of policy is appropriate.
What is the best landlord insurance for a new landlord?
For a new landlord, the best policy is one that clearly covers the property’s actual use, provides appropriate dwelling and liability limits, and offers useful protection for rental-income interruption where needed.
Do not choose solely on price.
How can I lower my landlord insurance premium?
Compare multiple quotes, maintain the property, ask about available discounts, choose a deductible you can afford, and review your coverage regularly.
Can one policy cover multiple rental properties?
Some insurers offer options for multiple properties, while others have specific eligibility requirements.
If you own a rental portfolio, ask the insurer whether it offers a solution designed for multiple properties.
Key Takeaways
- The best landlord insurance depends on your property and risk profile.
- There is no single insurer that is cheapest for every landlord.
- Compare coverage and price together.
- Dwelling coverage protects the rental structure against qualifying covered losses.
- Liability coverage can help with certain third-party claims.
- Some policies can protect lost rental income after a qualifying covered event.
- Tenant belongings are generally not covered by the landlord’s policy.
- Short-term rentals require special attention.
- A standard homeowners policy should not automatically be assumed to cover a rental property.
- Compare deductibles, exclusions, limits, and endorsements—not just premiums.
- Review your policy whenever the property or rental arrangement changes.
Conclusion
Finding the best landlord insurance starts with understanding what your rental property actually needs.
The six providers discussed in this guide—American Family, Steadily, Travelers, biBerk, Proper, and State Farm—can serve different types of landlords. One may be better suited to a traditional rental, another to a real estate investor, and another to a short-term rental or landlord who prefers local-agent support.
But the best decision should never be based on a company name alone.
Compare quotes using similar coverage limits. Check the deductible. Understand exclusions. Confirm whether lost rental income is protected. Make sure your exact rental arrangement is allowed. And if your property changes, review your insurance again.
The cheapest policy is not always the best value. The better policy is the one that gives you appropriate protection for the risks you actually face.